| | Most Free Throws Made by a Player in a Reserve Game |
| | Rank | | Name | F T M | | Opponent | Game Date |
| | 1 | | Kaylynn Scher | 8 | | Wabash | 11/12/2016 |
| | Zariyah Hahn | 8 | | Guerin Catholic | 12/5/2017 |
| | Jahnia Smith | 8 | | Anderson | 12/3/2019 |
| | 4 | | Staci Kelley | 6 | | Huntington | 12/13/1984 |
| | Ayana Harvey | 6 | | Muncie Central | 11/11/2016 |
| | Kaylynn Scher | 6 | | Muncie Central | 11/11/2016 |
| | Markeisha Jackson | 6 | | Kokomo | 12/16/2016 |
| | Kaliyah Jones | 6 | | Mississinewa | 1/9/2018 |
| | 9 | | Markeisha Jackson | 5 | | Richmond | 1/6/2017 |
| | Ashanti Cardine | 5 | | Pendleton Heights | 10/31/2017 |
| | Zariyah Hahn | 5 | | Muncie Central | 11/10/2017 |
| | Zariyah Hahn | 5 | | Wabash | 11/11/2017 |
| | Kaliyah Jones | 5 | | Wabash | 11/11/2017 |
| | Zariyah Hahn | 5 | | Anderson | 11/28/2017 |
| | Olivia Aguilar | 5 | | Anderson | 11/28/2017 |
| | Olivia Aguilar | 5 | | Laf McCutcheon | 12/2/2017 |
| | Carmen Contreras | 5 | | Huntington | 12/9/2017 |
| | Shalay Jeffries | 5 | | Pendleton Heights | 10/30/2018 |
| | Ashanti Cardine | 5 | | Wabash | 11/10/2018 |
| | Mezzie Allen | 5 | | Laf Jeff | 1/26/2022 |
| | Mezzie Allen | 5 | | Purdue Poly Englewood | 11/9/2022 |
| | Kemani Thomas | 5 | | Southwood | 1/4/2023 |
| | 23 | | Lisa Glickfield | 4 | | Huntington | 12/13/1984 |
| | Kellise Owensby | 4 | | Madison Grant | 11/15/2003 |
| | Kendra Buchannon | 4 | | Anderson | 1/21/2006 |
| | Mariah Harris | 4 | | Noblesville | 1/16/2007 |
| | Chelsea Morton | 4 | | Madison Grant | 1/3/2008 |
| | Desirea Newsome | 4 | | Muncie Central | 1/5/2008 |
| | Sara Schroder | 4 | | Muncie Central | 1/5/2008 |
| | Katie Gadd | 4 | | Laf Harrison | 11/5/2016 |
| | Markeisha Jackson | 4 | | Indy Arsenal Tech | 11/26/2016 |
| | Ayana Harvey | 4 | | Anderson | 11/29/2016 |
| | Ayana Harvey | 4 | | Anderson | 11/29/2016 |
| | Courtney Williams | 4 | | Huntington | 12/10/2016 |
| | Olivia Aguilar | 4 | | Oak Hill | 11/7/2017 |
| | Ashanti Cardine | 4 | | Columbia City | 11/17/2017 |
| | Olivia Aguilar | 4 | | Guerin Catholic | 12/5/2017 |
| | Ashanti Cardine | 4 | | Kokomo | 12/15/2017 |
| | Olivia Aguilar | 4 | | Southwood | 1/3/2018 |
| | Ashanti Cardine | 4 | | Mississinewa | 1/9/2018 |
| | Tuesday, February 28, 2023 | Page 1 of 2 |