| | The Most Points Scored in a Game by the Reserve Team |
| | Rank | Mar Pts | Opp Scr | | Opponent | Game Date |
| | 1 | | 81 | 26 | | Madison Grant | 1/4/1994 |
| | 2 | | 67 | 30 | | Muncie Central | 11/13/2015 |
| | 3 | | 66 | 22 | | Alexandria | 1/23/2008 |
| | 4 | | 65 | 15 | | Anderson | 1/24/2009 |
| | 5 | | 64 | 11 | | Muncie North | 1/9/1985 |
| | 64 | 28 | | Logansport | 12/1/1990 |
| | 7 | | 63 | 15 | | And Madison Heights | 1/28/1993 |
| | 8 | | 62 | 20 | | Madison Grant | 12/18/1990 |
| | 9 | | 61 | 16 | | F W South | 12/21/1989 |
| | 61 | 26 | | Eastbrook | 1/20/1992 |
| | 11 | | 60 | 22 | | And Madison Heights | 1/30/1992 |
| | 60 | 15 | | Oak Hill | 11/20/1992 |
| | 60 | 15 | | Muncie Central | 1/11/1994 |
| | 14 | | 59 | 11 | | Mississinewa | 12/17/1985 |
| | 59 | 26 | | Anderson | 1/25/1992 |
| | 59 | 22 | | Eastbrook | 1/18/1993 |
| | 59 | 23 | | Columbia City | 12/11/1999 |
| | 59 | 40 | | Lafayette Jeff | 11/24/2007 |
| | 19 | | 58 | 15 | | Huntington | 12/15/1983 |
| | 58 | 27 | | Anderson | 12/11/1986 |
| | 58 | 41 | | Madison Grant | 1/29/1987 |
| | 22 | | 57 | 17 | | Muncie Central | 1/12/1993 |
| | 57 | 27 | | Mississinewa | 1/13/2009 |
| | 24 | | 56 | 15 | | Madison Grant | 1/18/2000 |
| | 56 | 32 | | Elwood | 1/10/2018 |
| | 26 | | 55 | 31 | | Lafayette Jeff | 11/25/1989 |
| | 27 | | 54 | 11 | | Kokomo | 2/12/1975 |
| | 54 | 10 | | Logansport | 11/28/1977 |
| | 54 | 18 | | Kokomo | 1/3/1984 |
| | 54 | 24 | | Oak Hill | 1/30/2007 |
| | 54 | 23 | | North Miami | 1/21/2009 |
| | 32 | | 53 | 28 | | Blackford | 1/8/1987 |
| | 53 | 6 | | F W South | 12/20/1990 |
| | 53 | 23 | | Manchester | 12/1/1992 |
| | 53 | 23 | | Mississinewa | 12/19/1992 |
| | 53 | 29 | | New Castle | 1/8/1994 |
| | 37 | | 52 | 4 | | Elwood | 1/5/1981 |
| | 52 | 36 | | Muncie North | 1/13/1982 |
| | Tuesday, February 28, 2023 | Page 1 of 1 |